"There are no miracles that violate the laws of nature. There are only events that violate our limited knowledge of the laws of nature."
– St. Augustine

President
Alan Hugenot, D.Sc.
Vice President
William Wilson, J.D.
Secretary
Treasurer
Karin Nemri, A.S., C.S.C.
Asst. Treasurer
Lee S. Lawrence, CPA
Editor-In-Chief
Michael E. Tymn, B.A., CPCU
President Emeritus
 Rev. Harry L. Serio, D.Min.
Executive Administrator
 Paul Hauser, J.D.
ASCS Board
of Directors
♦ Boyce Batey, B.A.
♦ Rosemary Ellen Guiley, B.A.
♦Stephen H. Hall, B.GS.
♦ Alan Hugenot, D.Sc.
♦ Lee E. Lawrence, CPA
♦ John Franklin Miller III, Ph.D.
♦ Karin Nemri, A.S., C.S.C.
♦ Rev. Harry L. Serio, D.Min.
♦ Yvonne Sneeden
♦ David Stang, J.D.
♦ Michael E. Tymn, B.A., CPCU
♦ William E. Wilson, J.D.
♦ Nancy Zingrone, Ph.D.
ASCS Advisory
Board
♦ Stafford Betty, Ph.D.
♦ Larry Dossey, M.D.
♦ Suzanne R. Giesemann
♦ Jean Houston, Ph.D.
♦ Stanley Krippner, Ph.D.
♦ Lawrence LeShan, Ph.D.
♦ Raymond A. Moody Jr., M.D., Ph.D.,
♦ Vernon M. Neppe, M.D., Ph.D, BN&NP, FRSSAf, DFAPA
♦ Anne Puryear, D.D.
♦ Herb Puryear, Ph.D.
♦ Charles T. Tart, Ph.D.
♦ John W. White, M.AT.
You are visiting the Evidence Room of the Garland Memorial Library

Case Scoring Tables

The CS (Certainty of Discarnate Source) and WR (Witness Reliability) scores are calculated objectively by answering a series of questions. See the Evidence Scoring System for details.

Books Banner

Scoring for Case 9 - Good Ships and Witches

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M11 -25, M29 -2

200

35

165

WR

WR111 -6

100

6

94

Total

259


Scoring for Case 10 - Uncle Jerry's Watch

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -10, M13 -10, M26 -4, M29 -2

200

26

174

WR

WR201 -4, WR207 -3, WR208 -2, 219 -8, WR111 -6

100

23

77

Total

251


Scoring for Case 11 - Evidence by the Book

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M22 -7, M25 -10, M26 -4

200

21

179

WR

WR201 -4, WR207 -3, WR210 -4, WR219 -8, WR111 -6

100

25

75

Total

254


Scoring for Case 12 - Jung's Dream Library

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D16 -4, D20 -4, D22 -2

200

18

182

WR

WR300 -10, WR206 -10, WR207 -3, WR208 -2, WR219 -8, WR111 -6

100

39

61

Total

243


Scoring for Case 13 - Where's the Smoke?

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M22 -7, M25 -6, M26 -4, M28 -4

200

21

179

WR

WR205 -10, WR206 -5, WR207 -3, WR212 -9, WR217 -12, WR219 -8, WR111 -6

100

53

47

Total

226


Scoring for Case 14 - The R-101 Disaster

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 - 8, M29 - 2

200

10

190

WR

WR219 - 5

100

5

95

 

Total

285


Scoring for Case 15 - Relics Revealed & Revisited

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 - 5, M26 -4

200

9

191

WR

WR230 -4, WR207 -3, WR208 -2, 219 -5

100

14

86

 

Total

277


Scoring for Case 17 - The Ghosts in the Machines

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 - 8, M18 - 5, M28 - 4, M29 - 2

200

19

181

WR

WR230 -4, WR207 - 5, WR111 - 6

100

15

85

 

Total

266


Scoring for Case 18 - Dying to Meet Each Other

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R5 -4, R9 -8, R20 -2, R22 -3, x -5

200

26

174

WR

WR141 -2, WR121 -4, WR111 -3, WR112 -6

100

15

85

 

Total

259


Scoring for Case 19 - The Policeman and the Painter

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R15 -4, R20 -2

200

13

190

WR

WR105 -5, WR110 -12, WR111 -3

100

20

80

 

Total

270


Scoring for Case 20 - Death in the Garment District

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 - 4, R7 -3, R14 -8, R20 -2

200

17

183

WR

WR141 -2, WR121 -4, WR111 -3, WR112 -6

100

15

85
 

Total

268


Scoring for Case 21 - The Numbers of the Beast

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R7 -3, R14 -8, R20 -2

200

17

183

WR

WR141 -2, WR121 -4, WR111 - 3, WR112 -6

100

15

85

 

Total

268


Scoring for Case 22 - The Apprentice Murderer

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R5 -4, R10 -2, R20 -2

200

12

188

WR

WR141 -2, WR102 - 4, WR121 -4, WR111 -3, WR112 -6

100

19

81

 

Total

269


Scoring for Case 23 - A Town Reborn

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 - 4, R22 - 3, R24 -6

200

13

187

WR

WR141 -2, WR121 -4, WR112 - 6

100

12

88

 

Total

275


Scoring for Case 24 - New Meaning for ‘Soul Mate’

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

G1 -3, G10 -3

200

6

194

WR

W3 - 4, WR29 -5

100

9

91

 

Total

285


Scoring for Case 25 - The Remhurst Revenants

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D5 -4, D22 -6

200

18

182

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR12 -2, WR18 -3, WR29 -5, WR30 -6

100

26

74

 

Total

256


Scoring for Case 26 - A Very Confidential Secretary

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M13 -10

200

18

182

WR

W6 -6, WR11 -5,* W14 -6, WR29 -5, WR30 -6

100

28

72

* Cummins later recounted this case in a speech before the SPR, so two people have reported it.

Total

254


Scoring for Case 27 - The Dead Debtor

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D20 -4, D21 -2

200

14

186

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -10, WR11 -3, WR13 -3, WR20 -12, 22 -8, WR30 -6

100

47

53

 

Total

239


Scoring for Case 30 - The A.B.C. Séances

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M14 -5, M29 -2

200

15

185

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -5, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

23

77

 

Total

262


Scoring for Case 31 - The Singing Spirit

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -10, M14 -5, M26 -4, M28 -4, M29 -2

200

25

175

WR

W6 -6, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

29

71

 

Total

246


Scoring for Case 32 - Granddaughter Jerri's Watch

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D16 -4

200

12

188

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR20 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

42

58

 

Total

246


Scoring for Case 33 - The Wealthy Wall

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D5 -4

200

12

188

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR18 -3, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

33

67

 

Total

255


Scoring for Case 34 - A Different Sort of ‘Cold Case’

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

A11 -18

200

18

182

WR

W9 -5, WR10 -5, WR11 -3, WR15 -9, WR20 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

48

52

 

Total

234


Scoring for Case 35 - An Untimely Valentine

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -10, M18 -5

200

15

185

WR

W29 -8, WR30 -6

100

14

86

 

Total

271


Scoring for Case 36 - The Rebirth of Bridey Murphy

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R6 -10, R15 - 4, R22 - 3

200

17

183

WR

WR102 -4, WR121 -4,

100

8

92

 

Total

275


Scoring for Case 37 - Before the Evidence Melts Away

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D4 -10, D7 -12, D20 -4, D21 -2

200

28

172

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR20 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

42

58

 

Total

230


Scoring for Case 38 - The Killing of Klaas K.

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -12, M12 -15, M29 - 2

200

29

171

WR

W9 -10, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR20 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

47

53

 

Total

224


Scoring for Case 39 - The Mysterious Death of Edgar Vandy

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M18 -5

200

10

190

WR

W5 -5, WR29 -8

100

13

87

 

Total

277


Scoring for Case 40 - The Pearl Tie-Pin

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -12, M14 -5, M26 -4,

200

21

179

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

27

73

 

Total

252


Scoring for Case 41 - The Phantom Fingertips

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M14 -5, M29 -2

200

15

185

WR

W5 -7, WR11 -3, WR14 - 6, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

30

70

 

Total

255


Scoring for Case 42 - Icelandic Leg Hunting

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M18 -5, M26 -4, M28-4, M29 -2,

200

21

180

WR

W9 -10,W11 -5, WR19 -6, WR29 - 8, WR30 -6

100

35

65

 

Total

245


Scoring for Case 43 - From Bois to Boyce

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M12 -15, M28 -4, M29-2

200

29

171

WR

W7 -8, WR11 -3, WR15 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

37

63

 

Total

234


Scoring for Case 44 - Cloak and Danger

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D5 -4, D21 -2

200

14

186

WR

W8 -5, WR11 -3, WR13 -3, WR29 -8

100

19

81

 

Total

267


Scoring for Case 45 - The Return of Mary Roff

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M13 -10

200

15

185

WR

W9 -10, WR29 -5

100

15

85

 

Total

270


Scoring for Case 46 - The Rationalist Spirit

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M14 -5, M29 -2

200

15

185

WR

W6 -6, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR29 -5, WR30 -6

100

26

74

 

Total

259


Scoring for Case 47 - Young Soldiers Never Die, Either

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M811 -5, M823 -4, M826 -2

200

19

181

WR

W6 -6, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

29

71

 

Total

252


Scoring for Case 48 - Friends and Strangers

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M85 - 5, M826 - 2

200

7

193

WR

W3 - 4, WR14 - 6, WR29 - 5

100

18

82

 

Total

275


Scoring for Case 49 - Swept to the Sea

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -12, M11 -5, M23 -4

200

21

179

WR

W9 -10, WR10 -2,W11 -3, WR14 -6, WR18 -3, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

38

62

 

Total

241


Scoring for Case 50 - The Unexpected Husband

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D4 -12, D7 -12, D9 -10,

200

34

166

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR18 -3, WR29 -5, WR30 -6

100

30

70

 

Total

236


Scoring for Case 51 - Global Blinking

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

A2 -10, A14 -12

200

22

178

WR

W9 -5, WR11 -3, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

22

78

Total

256


Scoring for Case 52 - The Books in the Iron Box

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M19 - 7, M22 - 10, M26 - 2

200

19

181

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -10, WR13 -3, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

31

69

Total

250


Scoring for Case 53 - The Post-It That Wouldn't Die

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

A6 -10, A14 -12

200

22

178

WR

W9 -5, WR10 -10, WR11 -3, WR15 -9, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

41

59

Total

237


Scoring for Case 54 - Deer Thoughts

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M31 -5, M32 -2, M34 -6

200

13

187

WR

W5 -5, WR12 -2, WR20 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -4

100

31

69

Total

256


Scoring for Case 55 - Blanche Writes a Note

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

H5- 13, H8 - 7

200

20

180

WR

W7 -8, WR11 -5, WR14 -6, WR18 -3, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

36

64

Total

244


Scoring for Case 56 - Soule Proves the Soul

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M15 -11, M23 -4, M26 -2

200

17

183

WR

W6 -6, WR11 -3, WR13 -3, WR29 -8

100

20

80

Total

263


Scoring for Case 57 - The Unknown Plot

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -12, M15 -5, M23 -4

200

21

179

WR

W9 -10, WR11 -5, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

29

71

Total

250


Scoring for Case 58 - The Prince and the Servant Girl

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R6 -10, R16 -2, R20 -2, R22 -3

200

21

174

WR

WR141 -2, 102 -4, 121 -4, 111 -3, 112 -6

100

19

81

Total

255


Scoring for Case 59 — A Submariner Resurfaces

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R16 -2

200

6

194

WR

WR141 -2, WR102 -4, WR121 -4

100

10

90

Total

284


Scoring for Case 60 – The Strangers Were Lovers

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R5 -4, R16 -2, R22 -3

200

13

187

WR

WR141 -2, WR121 -4

100

6

94

Total

281


Scoring for Case 61 – Family Lost & Found

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R16 -3, R20 -2

200

9

191

WR

WR105 -10, 120 -5, 121 -4, 111 -3

100

22

78

Total

269


Scoring for Case 62 – The Picture of Raymond Lodge

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M14 -5, M29 -2

200

12

188

WR

W3 -4, WR27 -13, WR30 -6

100

23

77

Total

265


Scoring for Case 63 – Round Trip To Allentown

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R7 -3, R16 -2, R20 -2, R22 -3

200

14

186

WR

WR141 -2, WR102 -4, WR121 -4, WR111 -3

100

13

87

Total

273


Scoring for Case 64 – A Cameo Reappearance

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M18 -5, M26 -4

200

9

191

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

27

73

Total

264



Scoring for Case 65 – One More Mission

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C -6

200

6

194

WR

WR120 -5, WR121 -4

100

9

91

Total

285


Scoring for Case 66 – The 'Deadicated' Reporter

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M14 -5, M28 -4, M29 -2

200

16

184

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -5, WR11 -3, WR12 -2, WR29 -8

100

23

77

Total

261


Scoring for Case 67 – Anna's Amazing Abilities

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

S4 -2, S7 -12

200

14

186

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -3, WR13 -3, WR29 -8

100

18

82

Total

268


Scoring for Case 68 – The Unforgotten Coin

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M13 -10, M26 -4

200

22

178

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -3, WR12 -2, WR29 -5

100

14

86

Total

264


Scoring for Case 69 – The Murder of Jacqueline Poole

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M13 -10, M26 -4

200

19

181

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -5, WR29 -5

100

14

86

Total

267


Scoring for Case 70 – Fire and Iceland

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M14 -5, M26 -4, M28 -4, M29 -2

200

20

180

WR

W3 -4, WR29 -5

100

9

91

Total

271


Scoring for Case 71 – A Country Revival

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M13 -10,

200

15

185

WR

W8 -5, WR29 -5

100

10

90

Total

275


Scoring for Case 72 – Having A Friend

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: a -6, e -3, i -3, k -2, m -2

200

16

184

WR

WR101 -8, WR103 -6, , WR111 -3, WR112 -6

100

23

77

Total

261


Scoring for Case 73 – Where There's A Will

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

Q99 -6, D3 -8, D16 -7, D18 -6

200

27

173

WR

WR300 -10, WR207 -3, WR219 -5

100

18

82

Total

255


Scoring for Case 74 – Guns and Rebirth

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: a -6, i -3, k -2, m -2

200

13

187

WR

WR103 -6, WR112 -6

100

12

88

Total

275


Scoring for Case 75 – My Mother's Brother Is My Father's Son

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: 4 -6, e -3, i -6, k -2, m -2

200

19

181

WR

WR101 -4, WR103 -6, WR121 -4

100

14

86

Total

267


Scoring for Case 76 – The Spirits Seller's Spirit

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: a -6, i -3, k -2

200

11

189

WR

WR121 -4

100

4

96

Total

285


Scoring for Case 77 – Keeping Them In the Family

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: e -3, h -7, m-2

200

12

188

WR

WR101 -4, WR103 -6,

100

10

90

Total

278


Scoring for Case 78 – Coming Back Down Under

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R7 -3, R25 -3

200

10

190

WR

WR102 -4, WR121 -4, WR112 -6

100

14

86

Total

276


Scoring for Case 79 – Ex-Actor Makes a Comeback

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: a -6, m -2

200

8

192

WR

WR112 -6

100

6

94

Total

286


Scoring for Case 80 – A Tale of Two Tattoos

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -12, 14 -5, 26-4

200

21

192

WR

WR230 -4, 207 -3, 210 -4, 219 -8, 112 -6

100

25

75

Total

264


Scoring for Case 81 – Scotland Redux

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

a -6, e -3, k -2, m -2, x -10

200

23

177

WR

101 -4, 121 -4, 111 -3

100

11

89

Total

266


ASCS Library Floorplan


Comments and suggestions regarding the library should be directed to the Academy Librarian,
Miles Edward Allen
E-mail: m-media@comcast.net
Periodical Room
Aisle
P-1  ASCS Journals
P-2 ASCS Conference Proceedings
P-3 ASCS Searchlight (Bulletin/Newsletter)
P-4 Spirituality Matters (On-line)
P-5 Periodicals of Other Organizations

Book & A/V Room
Aisle
B-1 By Members of the Academy
B-2 Compilations of Evidence
B-3 Evoked Communications: Mediums, etc.
B-4 Recall of Past Lives
B-5 Spontaneous: ADCs & NDAs
B-6 NDEs / OBEs
B-7 Instrumental / Electronic
B-8 Physical Phenomena
B-9 Health & Well Being
B-20 History
B-25 Classics
B-30 Channeled Teachings
B-40 Fiction