[an error occurred while processing this directive]
"There are no miracles that violate the laws of nature. There are only events that violate our limited knowledge of the laws of nature."
– St. Augustine
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
You are visiting the Evidence Room of the Garland Memorial Library

Case Scoring Tables

The CS (Certainty of Discarnate Source) and WR (Witness Reliability) scores are calculated objectively by answering a series of questions. See the Evidence Scoring System for details.

Books Banner

Scoring for Case 9 - Good Ships and Witches

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M11 -25, M29 -2

200

35

165

WR

WR111 -6

100

6

94

Total

259


Scoring for Case 10 - Uncle Jerry's Watch

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -10, M13 -10, M26 -4, M29 -2

200

26

174

WR

WR201 -4, WR207 -3, WR208 -2, 219 -8, WR111 -6

100

23

77

Total

251


Scoring for Case 11 - Evidence by the Book

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M22 -7, M25 -10, M26 -4

200

21

179

WR

WR201 -4, WR207 -3, WR210 -4, WR219 -8, WR111 -6

100

25

75

Total

254


Scoring for Case 12 - Jung's Dream Library

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D16 -4, D20 -4, D22 -2

200

18

182

WR

WR300 -10, WR206 -10, WR207 -3, WR208 -2, WR219 -8, WR111 -6

100

39

61

Total

243


Scoring for Case 13 - Where's the Smoke?

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M22 -7, M25 -6, M26 -4, M28 -4

200

21

179

WR

WR205 -10, WR206 -5, WR207 -3, WR212 -9, WR217 -12, WR219 -8, WR111 -6

100

53

47

Total

226


Scoring for Case 14 - The R-101 Disaster

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 - 8, M29 - 2

200

10

190

WR

WR219 - 5

100

5

95

 

Total

285


Scoring for Case 15 - Relics Revealed & Revisited

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 - 5, M26 -4

200

9

191

WR

WR230 -4, WR207 -3, WR208 -2, 219 -5

100

14

86

 

Total

277


Scoring for Case 17 - The Ghosts in the Machines

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 - 8, M18 - 5, M28 - 4, M29 - 2

200

19

181

WR

WR230 -4, WR207 - 5, WR111 - 6

100

15

85

 

Total

266


Scoring for Case 18 - Dying to Meet Each Other

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R5 -4, R9 -8, R20 -2, R22 -3, x -5

200

26

174

WR

WR141 -2, WR121 -4, WR111 -3, WR112 -6

100

15

85

 

Total

259


Scoring for Case 19 - The Policeman and the Painter

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R15 -4, R20 -2

200

13

190

WR

WR105 -5, WR110 -12, WR111 -3

100

20

80

 

Total

270


Scoring for Case 20 - Death in the Garment District

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 - 4, R7 -3, R14 -8, R20 -2

200

17

183

WR

WR141 -2, WR121 -4, WR111 -3, WR112 -6

100

15

85
 

Total

268


Scoring for Case 21 - The Numbers of the Beast

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R7 -3, R14 -8, R20 -2

200

17

183

WR

WR141 -2, WR121 -4, WR111 - 3, WR112 -6

100

15

85

 

Total

268


Scoring for Case 22 - The Apprentice Murderer

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R5 -4, R10 -2, R20 -2

200

12

188

WR

WR141 -2, WR102 - 4, WR121 -4, WR111 -3, WR112 -6

100

19

81

 

Total

269


Scoring for Case 23 - A Town Reborn

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 - 4, R22 - 3, R24 -6

200

13

187

WR

WR141 -2, WR121 -4, WR112 - 6

100

12

88

 

Total

275


Scoring for Case 24 - New Meaning for ‘Soul Mate’

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

G1 -3, G10 -3

200

6

194

WR

W3 - 4, WR29 -5

100

9

91

 

Total

285


Scoring for Case 25 - The Remhurst Revenants

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D5 -4, D22 -6

200

18

182

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR12 -2, WR18 -3, WR29 -5, WR30 -6

100

26

74

 

Total

256


Scoring for Case 26 - A Very Confidential Secretary

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M13 -10

200

18

182

WR

W6 -6, WR11 -5,* W14 -6, WR29 -5, WR30 -6

100

28

72

* Cummins later recounted this case in a speech before the SPR, so two people have reported it.

Total

254


Scoring for Case 27 - The Dead Debtor

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D20 -4, D21 -2

200

14

186

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -10, WR11 -3, WR13 -3, WR20 -12, 22 -8, WR30 -6

100

47

53

 

Total

239


Scoring for Case 30 - The A.B.C. Séances

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M14 -5, M29 -2

200

15

185

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -5, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

23

77

 

Total

262


Scoring for Case 31 - The Singing Spirit

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -10, M14 -5, M26 -4, M28 -4, M29 -2

200

25

175

WR

W6 -6, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

29

71

 

Total

246


Scoring for Case 32 - Granddaughter Jerri's Watch

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D16 -4

200

12

188

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR20 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

42

58

 

Total

246


Scoring for Case 33 - The Wealthy Wall

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D5 -4

200

12

188

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR18 -3, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

33

67

 

Total

255


Scoring for Case 34 - A Different Sort of ‘Cold Case’

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

A11 -18

200

18

182

WR

W9 -5, WR10 -5, WR11 -3, WR15 -9, WR20 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

48

52

 

Total

234


Scoring for Case 35 - An Untimely Valentine

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -10, M18 -5

200

15

185

WR

W29 -8, WR30 -6

100

14

86

 

Total

271


Scoring for Case 36 - The Rebirth of Bridey Murphy

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R6 -10, R15 - 4, R22 - 3

200

17

183

WR

WR102 -4, WR121 -4,

100

8

92

 

Total

275


Scoring for Case 37 - Before the Evidence Melts Away

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D4 -10, D7 -12, D20 -4, D21 -2

200

28

172

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR20 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

42

58

 

Total

230


Scoring for Case 38 - The Killing of Klaas K.

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -12, M12 -15, M29 - 2

200

29

171

WR

W9 -10, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR20 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

47

53

 

Total

224


Scoring for Case 39 - The Mysterious Death of Edgar Vandy

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M18 -5

200

10

190

WR

W5 -5, WR29 -8

100

13

87

 

Total

277


Scoring for Case 40 - The Pearl Tie-Pin

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -12, M14 -5, M26 -4,

200

21

179

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

27

73

 

Total

252


Scoring for Case 41 - The Phantom Fingertips

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M14 -5, M29 -2

200

15

185

WR

W5 -7, WR11 -3, WR14 - 6, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

30

70

 

Total

255


Scoring for Case 42 - Icelandic Leg Hunting

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M18 -5, M26 -4, M28-4, M29 -2,

200

21

180

WR

W9 -10,W11 -5, WR19 -6, WR29 - 8, WR30 -6

100

35

65

 

Total

245


Scoring for Case 43 - From Bois to Boyce

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M12 -15, M28 -4, M29-2

200

29

171

WR

W7 -8, WR11 -3, WR15 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

37

63

 

Total

234


Scoring for Case 44 - Cloak and Danger

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D3 -8, D5 -4, D21 -2

200

14

186

WR

W8 -5, WR11 -3, WR13 -3, WR29 -8

100

19

81

 

Total

267


Scoring for Case 45 - The Return of Mary Roff

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M13 -10

200

15

185

WR

W9 -10, WR29 -5

100

15

85

 

Total

270


Scoring for Case 46 - The Rationalist Spirit

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M14 -5, M29 -2

200

15

185

WR

W6 -6, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR29 -5, WR30 -6

100

26

74

 

Total

259


Scoring for Case 47 - Young Soldiers Never Die, Either

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M811 -5, M823 -4, M826 -2

200

19

181

WR

W6 -6, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

29

71

 

Total

252


Scoring for Case 48 - Friends and Strangers

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M85 - 5, M826 - 2

200

7

193

WR

W3 - 4, WR14 - 6, WR29 - 5

100

18

82

 

Total

275


Scoring for Case 49 - Swept to the Sea

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -12, M11 -5, M23 -4

200

21

179

WR

W9 -10, WR10 -2,W11 -3, WR14 -6, WR18 -3, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

38

62

 

Total

241


Scoring for Case 50 - The Unexpected Husband

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

D4 -12, D7 -12, D9 -10,

200

34

166

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -2, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR18 -3, WR29 -5, WR30 -6

100

30

70

 

Total

236


Scoring for Case 51 - Global Blinking

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

A2 -10, A14 -12

200

22

178

WR

W9 -5, WR11 -3, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

22

78

Total

256


Scoring for Case 52 - The Books in the Iron Box

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M19 - 7, M22 - 10, M26 - 2

200

19

181

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -10, WR13 -3, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

31

69

Total

250


Scoring for Case 53 - The Post-It That Wouldn't Die

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

A6 -10, A14 -12

200

22

178

WR

W9 -5, WR10 -10, WR11 -3, WR15 -9, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

41

59

Total

237


Scoring for Case 54 - Deer Thoughts

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M31 -5, M32 -2, M34 -6

200

13

187

WR

W5 -5, WR12 -2, WR20 -12, WR29 -8, WR30 -4

100

31

69

Total

256


Scoring for Case 55 - Blanche Writes a Note

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

H5- 13, H8 - 7

200

20

180

WR

W7 -8, WR11 -5, WR14 -6, WR18 -3, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

36

64

Total

244


Scoring for Case 56 - Soule Proves the Soul

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M15 -11, M23 -4, M26 -2

200

17

183

WR

W6 -6, WR11 -3, WR13 -3, WR29 -8

100

20

80

Total

263


Scoring for Case 57 - The Unknown Plot

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -12, M15 -5, M23 -4

200

21

179

WR

W9 -10, WR11 -5, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

29

71

Total

250


Scoring for Case 58 - The Prince and the Servant Girl

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R6 -10, R16 -2, R20 -2, R22 -3

200

21

174

WR

WR141 -2, 102 -4, 121 -4, 111 -3, 112 -6

100

19

81

Total

255


Scoring for Case 59 — A Submariner Resurfaces

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R16 -2

200

6

194

WR

WR141 -2, WR102 -4, WR121 -4

100

10

90

Total

284


Scoring for Case 60 – The Strangers Were Lovers

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R5 -4, R16 -2, R22 -3

200

13

187

WR

WR141 -2, WR121 -4

100

6

94

Total

281


Scoring for Case 61 – Family Lost & Found

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R16 -3, R20 -2

200

9

191

WR

WR105 -10, 120 -5, 121 -4, 111 -3

100

22

78

Total

269


Scoring for Case 62 – The Picture of Raymond Lodge

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M14 -5, M29 -2

200

12

188

WR

W3 -4, WR27 -13, WR30 -6

100

23

77

Total

265


Scoring for Case 63 – Round Trip To Allentown

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R7 -3, R16 -2, R20 -2, R22 -3

200

14

186

WR

WR141 -2, WR102 -4, WR121 -4, WR111 -3

100

13

87

Total

273


Scoring for Case 64 – A Cameo Reappearance

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M18 -5, M26 -4

200

9

191

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -3, WR14 -6, WR29 -8, WR30 -6

100

27

73

Total

264



Scoring for Case 65 – One More Mission

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C -6

200

6

194

WR

WR120 -5, WR121 -4

100

9

91

Total

285


Scoring for Case 66 – The 'Deadicated' Reporter

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M14 -5, M28 -4, M29 -2

200

16

184

WR

W8 -5, WR10 -5, WR11 -3, WR12 -2, WR29 -8

100

23

77

Total

261


Scoring for Case 67 – Anna's Amazing Abilities

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

S4 -2, S7 -12

200

14

186

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -3, WR13 -3, WR29 -8

100

18

82

Total

268


Scoring for Case 68 – The Unforgotten Coin

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M7 -8, M13 -10, M26 -4

200

22

178

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -3, WR12 -2, WR29 -5

100

14

86

Total

264


Scoring for Case 69 – The Murder of Jacqueline Poole

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M13 -10, M26 -4

200

19

181

WR

W3 -4, WR11 -5, WR29 -5

100

14

86

Total

267


Scoring for Case 70 – Fire and Iceland

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M14 -5, M26 -4, M28 -4, M29 -2

200

20

180

WR

W3 -4, WR29 -5

100

9

91

Total

271


Scoring for Case 71 – A Country Revival

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M5 -5, M13 -10,

200

15

185

WR

W8 -5, WR29 -5

100

10

90

Total

275


Scoring for Case 72 – Having A Friend

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: a -6, e -3, i -3, k -2, m -2

200

16

184

WR

WR101 -8, WR103 -6, , WR111 -3, WR112 -6

100

23

77

Total

261


Scoring for Case 73 – Where There's A Will

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

Q99 -6, D3 -8, D16 -7, D18 -6

200

27

173

WR

WR300 -10, WR207 -3, WR219 -5

100

18

82

Total

255


Scoring for Case 74 – Guns and Rebirth

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: a -6, i -3, k -2, m -2

200

13

187

WR

WR103 -6, WR112 -6

100

12

88

Total

275


Scoring for Case 75 – My Mother's Brother Is My Father's Son

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: 4 -6, e -3, i -6, k -2, m -2

200

19

181

WR

WR101 -4, WR103 -6, WR121 -4

100

14

86

Total

267


Scoring for Case 76 – The Spirits Seller's Spirit

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: a -6, i -3, k -2

200

11

189

WR

WR121 -4

100

4

96

Total

285


Scoring for Case 77 – Keeping Them In the Family

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: e -3, h -7, m-2

200

12

188

WR

WR101 -4, WR103 -6,

100

10

90

Total

278


Scoring for Case 78 – Coming Back Down Under

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

R2 -4, R7 -3, R25 -3

200

10

190

WR

WR102 -4, WR121 -4, WR112 -6

100

14

86

Total

276


Scoring for Case 79 – Ex-Actor Makes a Comeback

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

C: a -6, m -2

200

8

192

WR

WR112 -6

100

6

94

Total

286


Scoring for Case 80 – A Tale of Two Tattoos

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

M8 -12, 14 -5, 26-4

200

21

192

WR

WR230 -4, 207 -3, 210 -4, 219 -8, 112 -6

100

25

75

Total

264


Scoring for Case 81 – Scotland Redux

Scale

Question ID – Points Subtracted

Base

Minus

Equals

CS

a -6, e -3, k -2, m -2, x -10

200

23

177

WR

101 -4, 121 -4, 111 -3

100

11

89

Total

266

[an error occurred while processing this directive]